Recent ISP reviews.
Thu, August 28, 2008
    ISP List    
 
ISP Reviews
 
Editorials
 
Forum
 
Dialup Networking
HowTo
 
How To Select
an ISP
 
DUN Errors
 
Review Your ISP
 
About The ISP List
 
The Rating Groups:

We are re­view­ing ran­dom­ly pi­cked In­ter­net Ser­vi­ce pro­vi­ders in the fol­lo­wing ma­jor grou­ps:
· Free ISPs
· Low-cost ISPs
· Special Interest ISPs
· Major ISPs
· General (All other)

The Rating Categories:

The fi­nal ra­ting for eve­ry ISP we re­view is ge­ne­ra­ted from the in­di­vi­du­al ra­tings that our re­view­ers gi­ve it. No­te: The fi­nal ra­ting is NOT an a­ve­ra­ge of the fol­lo­wing six ra­tings; each of the­se thin­gs is weig­h­ted dif­fe­re­n­t­ly to co­me up with the fi­nal o­ve­r­all ra­ting.

· Longevity (age)
· Speed, latency, "busies"
· Customer Support
· Features
· Value (price, extra fees)
  and
· Reviewer's Angle.

  This last ra­ting ba­si­ca­l­ly lets a re­view­er sway the fi­n­al ra­ting--ei­ther hi­gh­er or lo­wer--ba­sed on the re­view­er's ex­pe­ri­e­n­ce with an ISP. He­re's an ex­a­m­ple: An ISP mi­ght ha­ve re­al­ly go­od con­ne­c­ti­vi­ty but re­al­ly bad sup­port--so it gets a low Re­view­er's An­gle ra­ting to ke­ep the ove­r­all ra­ting low, sin­ce the ISP ul­ti­ma­te­ly isn't fun to use. Or an ISP mi­ght ha­ve po­or web­si­te and li­mi­ted set of ex­tra fea­tu­res but ha­ve a very good ser­vi­ce and sup­port--so it mi­ght get a hi­gh Re­view­er's An­gle to bo­ost the over­all ra­ting a bit.

· We here at The ISP List build our re­views aro­und ce­r­tain guide­li­nes, but keep in mi­nd that we al­so ha­ve dif­fe­rent re­view­ers with dif­fe­rent opi­ni­ons and wri­ting sty­les. Wri­ters aren't ex­pec­ted to stri­c­tly fol­low the re­views and ra­tings of ISPs that they di­dn't re­view them­selv­es. Some­ti­mes this leads to no­ti­ce­able dif­fe­ren­ces be­t­we­en re­views and ra­t­ings of dif­fe­rent ISPs.

· The bot­tom li­ne is that no two co­m­pa­ni­es are ali­ke, and no two sets of ne­eds are the sa­me the­re­fo­re our re­views con­si­der each pro­vi­der on its own me­rits. This me­ans that ev­en for si­mi­lar ISPs, we re­view each in­di­vi­du­al com­pa­ny by it­self on its own terms, in­stead of just try­ing to keep our ra­tings of the­se ISPs in li­ne with each other. So even tho­ugh our re­vi­ews will ide­al­ly be wri­t­ten with the sa­me ex­act sta­n­dards, dif­fe­rent pe­o­ple wri­te for The ISP List -- so not eve­ry re­view will fol­low eve­ry oth­er re­view 100 per­cent of the time.

Disclaimer:

· Copyrights reserved.
· Materials published here may not be reproduced without an explicit written permission of The ISP List.
· The texts of these reviews have been provided by the independent reviewers and are only monitored for offensive or damaging material.
· Factual details provided by the authors (and their agenda or motives for posting their messages) may not be checked.
· The views expressed on this page are those of the individuals involved and may not coincide with the those of The ISP List.

Latest reviews

 Msn Internet Access Category: Major ISPs  

Name: Msn Internet Access
Web Address: www.msn.com
Cost: $21.95/month, for dialup (the first 2 months are free) $39.95-$49.95/month for Broadband.
Setup Fee: None for dialup, $49.95 for Broadband
Hours included: Unlimited
Toll-free phone: 1-866-900-6768
Reviewed on: Tue Jun 3 2003
Reviewed by: Jeni Rae
Rating:

JR here, rockin' and rollin' to Adam Ant's "Goody Two Shoes." Love those 80's hits! Feelin' so good, I gotta share this:

Toddler Property Laws:

  1. If I like it, it's mine.
  2. If it's in my hand, it's mine.
  3. If I can take it from you, it's mine.
  4. If I had it a little while ago, it's mine.
  5. If it's mine, it must never appear to be yours in any way.
  6. If I'm doing or building something, all the pieces are mine.
  7. If it looks just like mine, it's mine.
  8. If I think it's mine, it's mine.
  9. If I. . . Oops! I'm sorry; I goofed! Instead of typing in the Toddler Property Laws, I've been typing in Bill Gates' primary Business Plan.
Oi! I know...but it had to be said. While Microsoft is booming, there are some of us (no names, please) who prefer to only open a window when we want to let in a cool breeze.

That said, we need to be fair and give you an unbiased review of a popular Microsoft ISP (did I pull that off without smiling?).

Ok┘.here we go. MSN.
It's better with the butterfly. How much do they pay that guy to dress up in tights and butterfly wings and jump around my TV during commercial breaks?

In the past few years, MSN has tried to catch up with AOL's fame. With everything they offer, it's impossible to make an adequate review in this short venue. But since I'm a determined lil' thing, I'll give it a try.

Pricing: MSN has so many promotions right now it'll make your head spin. From bribing you with "MSN bucks" to applying for and using a Citi card, you can find a package that's right for you. A bit of advise though: read EVERYTHING before you sign up. Some of these promotions require you to make commitments, some up to 4 years. I can't commit to living in the same house for that long, let alone an ISP.

I should add that for those weird people who actually have a life, MSN offers a cheaper package. For $9.95/month, you can get 20 hours. Pretty good deal if it's right for you. Personally, I can use up those 20 hours in a day.

MSN also has a fun, visually and audibly appealing start page. It's great for morale to see your own icon and hear your own name when you sign on.

Software---the bribe of all bribes. This is what MSN offers:

  • Dashboard --- a customizable navigation bar
  • Shared browsing
  • "My MSN"
  • Download Manager
  • MSN calendar
  • Tools for the home
  • MSN Photos Plus (with Microsoft Picture It! Photo Editing Software)
  • MSN Money Plus

MSN also brags about their enhanced parental controls. Hence the man-butterfly in all of their commercials. In them you see a mom and kids walking down a street with the butterfly two steps ahead of them, covering up anything that may be offensive to the kiddies. Highly entertaining. Instead of just having a broad shield, you're able to fine-tune your settings to better fit your needs. You can set separate settings for browsers, email, dictionary, calendars, downloading files, etc. You can also have a report printed out each time a session is done, so you know exactly what was done. This is pushing it a bit in my book. Can we say, "controlling?"

Another big plus: MSN offers help with switching from other ISP's. I don't know about you, but my ISP holds my life. Addresses, favorite places, personal settings, buddy lists, etc. To switch would be a huge pain, and a risk of losing important stuff. The fact that MSN understands and addresses this earns them another gold star.

On the downside: the dreaded customer service. Recently I underwent a research project where I was required to call 150 big named companies and try to get some info from them. The operative word here being, "try." I started believing that these people were told in their weekly training meetings to be as uncooperative as they could when people call. 45 minute hold times, transferred to everyone in the office, and even an "accidental" disconnect.

Such is the case with MSN. Word is they have too many customers to handle (next question: so why are they promoting it so strong right now?). Users complain of long hold times, rude operators, and billing fiascoes. I personally took my 2 month free trial last year, but when I asked to cancel it, they made it so hard and confusing I wasn't sure if I cancelled, or ordered a rubber duckie. Sure enough, our next bank statement showed that they charged us for the next 2 months. Yet another Bill Gates joke, I guess.

Time for the Pros/Cons nutshell:
PROS:

  • 24/7 customer support
  • Up to 9 email accounts
  • Lots of useful software
  • Email management options
  • First 2 months are free
  • The software is on most computers
CONS:
  • Complaints about customer service┘forever on hold
  • Frustrating and confusing billing department
  • Long 3 and 4 year contracts

Bottom line, True to Microsoft protocol, MSN offers lots of frills, but their ability to follow through is arguable. If they just spend more time and money on customer service, they'd be perfect. At any rate, if you are looking to be pampered and have your ego lifted every time you sign on, MSN does the job!

  Tell us your opinion Talk back
Stolen $ and identity - MSN wouldn't remove change... - by P Pharris 06/16/03
Zero Checking Of Sign-Up Users - by Anonymous 09/08/06
MSN - by Barb Domek 04/15/07

 
Please address all inquiries and questions to webmaster @ theisplist.com Copyright 2002, ISP Digest